PAUL McLAUGHLIN

A campaign to save the historic fishing boat which greets visitors to Hastings as they exit the railway station has divided local opinion.

The RX53 Dorothy Melinda is a traditional clinker-built wooden fishing boat, with the wheelhouse at the stern. It is one of only seven which now remain in the town. It has been on display on the roundabout outside the station for the last 15 or so years. But the years have taken their toll: the vessel is in urgent need of repair or destruction – depending on your point of view. Much of its hull is rotten, and the keel, stern and transom have all suffered from years of neglect. The upper structure is also in serious disrepair. 

Officers of Hastings Borough Council (HBC), which owns the boat and leases the land it sits on from Southeastern Railway, believe it is now beyond reasonable repair. Council Chief Executive Jane Hartnell recently announced that, despite ongoing maintenance over the years, the boat has become a “potential health and safety risk to the public, passing cars and buses”. 

An added factor is that HBC’s lease of the land from Southeastern Railway has now expired. Under its terms the council is obliged to remove the boat on termination. Ms Hartnell indicated that “it will not be possible at this late stage, with contractors instructed, and licenses and methodology agreed, to halt the process without considerable costs to HBC.”

- Advertisement -
St Michaels Hospice Run Advert

CROWDFUNDER CAMPAIGN

Peter Carney, a local historical enthusiast, is undeterred by the boat’s condition and has launched a campaign to save it. He has set up a crowdfunding page to raise an initial £5,000 to move the boat to a safe location and to work with a team of volunteers to help restore it to its former glory. 

£1,800 has so far been raised. Peter is confident that more money will be donated before the deadline. He has approached the East Hastings Angling Association to provide the vessel with a temporary home, and he is hopeful that a permanent home along the seafront will be secured by the time the restoration work is completed.

He understands the very strict financial limitations HBC is working within and accepts the council simply does not have the resources to embark on a lengthy and very costly restoration. However, in view of the level of support his campaign has received, he is optimistic there will be a change of heart and that the Dorothy Melinda will be reprieved.

Steve Barrow, who has been building and repairing wooden boats in Hastings for over 50 years, thinks the boat is just too rotten and is well beyond saving. Whilst sympathetic to Peter’s efforts to save the boat, he believes his campaign is misguided. “Whatever money is raised should be used to restore a vessel which could be saved rather than one that is just too far gone”, he says, noting there are more suitable boats along the beach which are in much better condition than the Dorothy Melinda. He pointed to the RX60, the Mandy Anne, which was abandoned and left to rot on the shingle behind the Net Huts for the last 20 years and which he believes, despite the conditions, could still be salvaged.

Back in the early 1980s, there were 44 boats working from Hastings beach, with a waiting list for spaces. There is now only a single wooden boat that regularly goes out to sea, and less than ten working boats in total. The near-collapse of the fishing industry in the town over this period can be attributed to many factors, including smaller fish stocks and the lack of government support, but it may not be long before all the traditional clinker-built wooden fishing boats have been discarded and lost. 

Restoration of the two historic Hastings lifeboats, the Priscilla Macbean and the Cyril and Lilian Bishop, both in the Old Town, shows it’s a popular cause and can be done. But it’s clearly a constant battle and takes time, effort and lots of money.


We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.

https://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/NEWS-Dorothy_1-1024x768.jpghttps://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/NEWS-Dorothy_1-150x150.jpgHIPNewsTop StoriesEast Hastings Angling Association,Hastings Borough Council,Jane Hartnell,Paul McLaughlin,Southeastern RailwayPAUL McLAUGHLIN A campaign to save the historic fishing boat which greets visitors to Hastings as they exit the railway station has divided local opinion. The RX53 Dorothy Melinda is a traditional clinker-built wooden fishing boat, with the wheelhouse at the stern. It is one of only seven which now remain...The Hastings & St Leonards non-profit community newspaper