Aldi versus Jempson in Competition for Rye Shoppers

HUGH SULLIVAN

The only supermarket of any size currently trading in Rye is Jempsons, opposite the railway station. Operating in tandem with its twin store in Peasmarsh, four miles to the north, it is a family business which has dominated local grocery shopping in this corner of East Sussex for several decades. That seems likely to change.

Hugh Sullivan
Aldi store in Ore -tenth anniversary in November

In June Aldi, the German supermarket giant, lodged a planning application with Rother District Council to develop a new supermarket on the A259 (Winchelsea Road) at the western edge of the town. The premises at issue are understood to be still owned, as it happens, by a different branch of the Jempson family involved in the haulage industry.

Aldi’s entry and expansion in Hastings over the past ten years – it opened its Ore supermarket in November 2014 and followed up with a second in Bexhill Road from September 2020 – were conducted in a distinctly competitive environment. Those stores have had to compete for market share with a range of alternative major providers already in place across Hastings and St Leonards: Tesco, Sainsburys, Morrisons, Asda and Lidl, as well as several branches of the Co-op and a host of corner stores. 

But although, in May this year, Jempsons belatedly teamed up with Morrisons to offer the latter’s own products at keener prices through its stores, the Rye locality has until now been rather less competitive. The nearest mainstream supermarket alternatives are Aldi in Ore, ten miles away, or Tesco or Waitrose in Tenterden, more than 12. Many Rye shoppers feel – and have expressed their view both in formal comments within the planning process and generally on social media – that for a long time Jempsons have got away with charging higher prices than they could or should have because of their comparative monopoly.

- Advertisement -
St Michaels Hospice Run Advert

PLANNING OPPOSITION

Be that as it may, Jempsons (with Morrisons) have not been slow to oppose the planning application. In a formally lodged objection statement, they have claimed that their current store “plays a key role in drawing shoppers into [Rye] Town Centre”, whereas Aldi’s “out-of-centre” proposal “will have a significantly adverse impact on the vitality and viability of Rye Town Centre”. A major reduction in Jempsons turnover “would almost certainly bring about [its] closure” and “would also lead to a significant decline in the number of shoppers visiting the rest of the Town Centre.” 

In a Facebook post on 11 September, Jempsons seemed to retract their closure prediction, saying: “We would like to add, if the Aldi store does go ahead, we don’t plan to close but can’t deny there will be some impact on our business.” However, in a more recent interview on BBC Radio Sussex, managing director Stephen Jempson suggested that post office services, currently hosted within the store, would be at risk.

There are two associated planning applications for residential developments to be built alongside. Permission for 16 two-, three- and four-bedroomed homes is sought by local company Decimus Property, while national retirement property specialists McCarthy Stone are promoting the building of 44 ‘retirement apartments’. 

The District Council planning committee was due to consider all three applications next month, but National Highways has lodged a response seeking more time to analyse potential traffic implications for the A259 road. 


We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.

https://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/NEWS-ALDI-1024x768.jpghttps://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/NEWS-ALDI-150x150.jpgHIPNewsAldi,Jempson,RyeAldi versus Jempson in Competition for Rye Shoppers HUGH SULLIVAN The only supermarket of any size currently trading in Rye is Jempsons, opposite the railway station. Operating in tandem with its twin store in Peasmarsh, four miles to the north, it is a family business which has dominated local grocery shopping...The Hastings & St Leonards non-profit community newspaper