A major fire broke out in the Old Town on the evening of Wednesday 18 January in a building due for demolition, part of which is Grade-II listed.

Saturdays burnt-out. Photo: Paul McLaughlin

Last month owners Oasis Developments Hastings Limited issued an application seeking planning permission from Hastings Borough Council (HBC) to demolish the former amusement arcade and nightclub premises at 39-41 George Street and to replace them with four ground floor retail shops and 21 flats above – 14 for sale or residential letting, seven as holiday lettings.

No 41, at one end, has a façade onto the street described by Historic Buildings & Places (a re-branding of the Ancient Monuments Society) as retaining a number of historic elements, including the platform to the upper levels, the stair and bow windows to the front elevation.

Much of the building, including this façade, was clearly in an already extremely dilapidated state, propped by scaffolding. The planning application described the building envelope as damaged by water penetration that “has structurally weakened the building throughout”. But why such a blaze should have broken out two days after the torrential rain which had caused floods at Priory Meadow less than half a mile away remains, at the time of going to press, unexplained. East Sussex Fire and Rescue Service, which attended the conflagration with ten pumps and an aerial ladder platform arriving from both the Ridge and Bohemia Road fire stations, has not so far expressed any public opinion as to its likely cause.

Broken usements. Photo: Paul McLaughlin.

Planning process

Submissions previously lodged by statutory authorities within the planning process indicate that the proposed development of shops and residential flats at the site would not be objected to in principle. HBC’s housing department, in particular, has stated willingness to support the application “on the basis that it will deliver much needed new homes”, though they want a 25% provision of affordable homes in the form of two ‘first homes’ and 3.25 that are affordable/social rents.

- Advertisement -
St Michaels Hospice Run Advert

However, Historic Buildings and Places were arguing that no. 41, the listed building, “has the capacity to be repaired and incorporated into the wider development, rather than demolished, enhancing its significance and contributing to the historic interest of the wider conservation area”. And HBC’s Marketing & Major Projects Manager Kevin Boorman, while offering general approval of the balance of residential and holiday accommodation, agreed – “I do not see a compelling reason for demolition [of the listed part], other than it is easier and cheaper to develop an empty site than convert it. The building has quite a presence at the entrance to George Street, and I think it should not be demolished, but remain. It can still be used for accommodation”.

It’s not immediately obvious that the fire damage has rendered these arguments academic. Further assessment is awaited.


We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.

https://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/DSC_0918-1024x680.jpghttps://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/DSC_0918-150x150.jpgHugh SullivanNews39-41 george street,demolition,fire,george street fire,HBC,Historic Buildings & Places,Kevin Boorman,oasis developments,oasis developments hastings limited,saturdaysA major fire broke out in the Old Town on the evening of Wednesday 18 January in a building due for demolition, part of which is Grade-II listed. Saturdays burnt-out. Photo: Paul McLaughlin Last month owners Oasis Developments Hastings Limited issued an application seeking planning permission from Hastings Borough Council...The Hastings & St Leonards non-profit community newspaper