Council Reform: Do People Just Not Care?
PAUL MCLAUGHLIN
The public consultations on the proposed changes to local government in Hastings and East Sussex are now underway, but so far there is little enthusiasm for what is being billed as the biggest shake-up to local council structures in more than half a century.

Stevenson Graham
A vox pop in Hastings town centre revealed that when asked what they thought of the changes, most people simply shrugged their shoulders and moved quickly on. “I don’t do politics.” was a popular refrain from many of those who were largely unaware of the proposed shake-up. A common view seems to be that the local council—whether in East Sussex or Hastings—has little impact on people’s daily lives, and that they are uninterested in what happens.
Liz, a young mother shuffling across Priory Meadow with shopping bags, said whatever happens cannot be any worse than the way things are at present. Hastings Borough Council is a “disaster,” she said. The “bus services are terrible, the potholes are dangerous and never get repaired, and council tax bills just go up and up.” When it was pointed out that the two services she mentioned were the responsibility of East Sussex County Council, she simply said, “they are all the same”, and walked on.
Even those who were aware of the reform plans – and there were not many–expressed little confidence that local services would improve with the creation of a new unitary council. Many seemed largely indifferent about likely changes to their bin collections, street parking or allotments.
The only time people became exercised was when it was pointed out to them that the proposed changes would spell the end of Hastings Borough Council. For many, this was a step too far and represented an attack on their local identity. Stevenson Graham expressed disbelief at the plan to scrap Hastings Borough Council: “It just feels wrong. We will be swallowed up by East Sussex, and Lewes is miles away. How are they going to understand what we need?”

Jane Carey echoed his concern: “How can we be sure our priorities will be taken seriously? Hastings faces unique challenges—high deprivation, struggling schools, housing problems. We need a council focused on Hastings, not a distant body disconnected from our everyday realities.”
Mel McCleary said Hastings Borough Council was “far from perfect” and had made “some baffling decisions,” notably withdrawing from the 1066 tourism initiative. She also agreed that a new unitary authority could potentially reduce bureaucracy and improve services but cautioned that the “potential loss of democratic accountability was a step too far.” She emphasised the “importance of a strong local council for the future of the town.”
Whilst acknowledging possible efficiency savings under a unitary council, Penny Beale doubted whether the Government would pass these on to fund the new authority properly. She also expressed concerns about the future of town assets like the Foreshore Trust and St Mary in the Castle.
The general mood of apathy was all too apparent last Thursday (12 June) when Hastings councillors gathered in Muriel Matters House for a public meeting to explain the local government reform proposals and to hear the views of residents. Only three people turned up, plus this HIP journalist.

Despite the pitiful attendance in the public gallery, the councillors presented their favoured reform options. Each spoke with heartfelt conviction, their voices carrying the passion that had originally drawn them into politics. As they outlined their visions for the town’s future, their pride was palpable, and they were united by the shared purpose of what was best for Hastings.
Green Councillor Julia Hilton, who recently stepped down as leader of Hastings BC to focus on local government reform, spoke in favour of plans for a new East Sussex unitary council covering the existing county council area. Judy Rogers for Labour favoured a smaller coastal unitary covering Hastings, Bexhill, and Eastbourne, whilst Paul Barnett of the Hastings Independents proposed abolishing the county council and devolving powers to the existing districts of Hastings, Rother, Wealden, Lewes, and Eastbourne, who would jointly manage key services through a shared board in a federated model.
It was generally agreed that the government’s timetable for local government reform was limited and meant that any meaningful engagement with the public was challenging.
Amid the discussions about simplifying council services and making efficient savings, Cllr John Cannan said he felt the reform was a cynical exercise to save money and destroy local accountability.
The Council’s consultation closes on 30 June and Cllr Becca Horn, the new Mayor of Hastings, who chaired the meeting with humour and a confident ease, said there have only been 500 or so responses to it so far. She contrasted this with the controversial Dog Control Public Space Protection Order consultation which generated almost 3000 responses.
The Council has produced a consultation leaflet which has been regularly shared on its social media platforms with a hard copy due to be delivered to each household in the town. Again, a quick vox pop suggests many residents are yet to receive this.
We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.


Leave a Reply