Changing of the Guard?
When Immigration Minister Robert Jenrick told Parliament on 29 March this year that the Home Office was intending to use an unidentified location in East Sussex for the housing of asylum seekers, he emphasised the need to find cheaper accommodation for them, not to detain them.
As soon as the former Northeye prison premises on the edge of Bexhill were confirmed as the site in question, his government colleague, Battle and Bexhill MP Huw Merriman, issued a statement. He assured his local constituents that their safety was his main concern, given that the future residents of the site would not be locked in or subject to curfew. He had been told that nearly 70% could expect to succeed in due course with their asylum claims, and drew from this the comforting idea that they would be highly motivated “[not] to break the law”.
But the enactment of the Illegal Migration Act at the end of last month seems to turn this perspective on its head. Section 1(a) of the Act “places a duty on the Secretary of State to make arrangements for the removal of certain persons who enter or arrive in the United Kingdom in breach of immigration control as soon as is reasonably practicable after their entry or arrival”. Section 1(c) provides for “the detention of persons who are subject to removal under this Act”.
If Home Secretary Suella Braverman really wants to make the Act effective, she surely has to start detaining the people concerned – and where is she going to do that?
Daniel Rushby of SUTR naturally condemns the whole direction of the policy. “When government ministers talk about ‘illegal immigrants’, ‘invasions’ and migrants bringing ‘criminal behaviour’,” he says, “they are deliberately stoking up racism against people seeking asylum. If the government were serious about stopping the small boats crossing the Channel, they could create safe routes for refugees to claim asylum. It is a political decision not to allow refugees from Afghanistan or Iraq or Iran or Sudan the same opportunity to claim asylum as they afford to refugees from the war in Ukraine. Ukrainians, quite rightly, have been welcomed, allowed to work and to contribute to our community. We believe this welcome should apply to all refugees, whatever their skin colour.”
Detention of asylum–seeking refugees should not, from Rushby’s political perspective, be in the Government’s contemplation. On the other hand, he admits he would not be surprised if Northeye were turned back into a detention site for this purpose. “I think the Home Office have been considering this all along,” he says.
For Nigel Jacklin and his NTN Group, who have generally welcomed the passing of the Act, it’s more of a dilemma. “The main concern identified by the Town Council at the April open meeting with residents was safety and security based on 1,200 men being able to roam freely,” says Jacklin. “The majority of residents don’t want it (the camp) or them (people who have arrived illegally). Opposition to illegal arrivals is widespread across the UK.
“No doubt most local residents would welcome the removal of people who have arrived illegally. Using the site as a detention centre is clearly a different proposal.”
He says that reports from when the site was used as a prison, initially for 250 inmates and then for 450, suggested it was well run and community relationships were good. But if detention of 1,200 “illegal arrivals” were to be considered, “residents would want to be consulted”.
We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.


Leave a Reply