Can Jews Criticise Israel from within the Labour Party?
A placard carried by Hastings Jewish activist Katy Colley to a Palestinian rally in London last Saturday – see adjacent picture – went viral, and she was interviewed about it on Sky News.

In the meantime former Hastings Borough councillor Leah Levane has been conducting a wider campaign to allow Jews who are members of the Labour party (or otherwise) to criticise Israeli government policy towards Palestinians without being branded antisemitic. In August this year, Jewish Voice for Labour, a group which she co-chairs, published data showing bizarrely that Jewish members (including Ms Levane) have been six times more likely than non-Jews to be investigated by the party for alleged antisemitism and nearly ten times more likely to be expelled – or in internal party language “auto-excluded”- from membership.
Ms Levane found her own party membership cancelled without the right of appeal during the Labour conference in October 2021 after signing an open letter and speaking at two fringe events organized by groups, retrospectively banned by the party, which challenged the extent of alleged antisemitism within it. Another former Hastings councilor Mike Howard, also Jewish, who had been a longstanding Labour member, was suspended on similar grounds in February 2021 and was not reinstated nor even had acknowledgement of his appeal before dying unexpectedly nine months later.
Ms Levane complains that the Board of Deputies of British Jews, which is an avowedly Zionist body and doesn’t represent all Jewish opinion in Britain, has been given an effective supervisory status in determining the threshold of acceptable views within the Labour party regarding Israel, Palestine, Zionism and antisemitism. However, there seems little prospect of any change while Sir Keir Starmer remains as leader. He told Sky News last week that the violence in Gaza was “entirely the responsibility of Hamas”. He went on to recall his first words as leader that he would “rip antisemitism out of the Labour party by the roots”.
We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.


There was little anti semitism on the left in politics but a huge amount on the extreme right often from proscribed organisations. Antisemitism is abhorrent and finding out about the Holocaust when I was a young teenager in the early 60s via Pathe News, visiting museums and reading books, made me want to join the Labour Party. But because of Corbyn’s leadership for a period in the Party, antisemitism was used as a weapon to get rid of the left who had not supported New Labour. Then Starmer got into power after Corbyn lost the 2019 election, by lying about ten pledges and pretending he was the natural continuation of socialist policies candidate. His some of his backers were and are Zionists and he and the Party have received donations from anti Corbyn pro Israel supporters. This explains his appalling position on no ceasefire and comments about food and water and medicines being cut off from Gaza. He and the Party I resigned from because of him, has colluded in Genocide and stood by allowing Netanyahu and his fascist ministers to treat Gazan children like worthless animals. The blood on their hands will go down in history and destroy the reputation of Israel. I must also state that I loathe Hamas and what they thought they would win for the people of Gaza out of the October 7th attack is beyond any rationale explanation. The propaganda put out by Israel on that attack has already been exposed as made up of truth and lies. No beheaded babies for example.