The Cost of Energy Security
Kent Barker considers the government’s dilemma in trying to achieve energy security, minimise fuel poverty, and meet its climate change targets.
I don’t know if you’ve noticed but energy prices seem to be rising at a rather alarming rate. Forecourt diesel prices have been nudging towards £2 a litre over the past few weeks. At one Hastings garage in 2020 you could buy petrol for 99p. Admittedly that was at the depth of lockdown, and it didn’t last for long, but even so, fuel prices almost doubling in just two years? The cost of filling up a family car’s tank shooting up from £60 to nearly £120!
Environmentalists might say ‘jolly good thing’. Get people out of their cars – or at the very least, driving less. Try public transport. Buy a bicycle. All very well for those in the town centre perhaps but not much cop if you live on the periphery, or out in the country, where hen’s teeth are a good deal more common than buses. Well then, buy an electric car! Fine if you can afford one, but environmentally rather wasteful to junk your existing three-quarters of a ton of metal and plastic. And your new vehicle’s lithium-ion battery requires a shed-load of energy to produce … and the electricity to charge it has to come from somewhere.


Domestic Oil up 126%
Anyway, it’s not just motoring that the energy crisis is hitting. It’s living. Take gas prices. Around 18 million households on standard tariffs are looking at an average increase of £693 – from £1,277 to £1,971 per year. And worse still, 4.5 million prepayment customers will see an average increase of £708 – from £1,309 to £2,017. Yes, that’s right. The poorer you are – i.e. more likely to have a prepayment meter – the bigger the increase in your bills. Mind you, all those who heat their homes with gas are at least covered by the so-called ‘energy price cap’ theoretically setting a ceiling. There’s no such thing for the 5 or 6 million people who have to use oil for domestic heating. That’s risen from 68.66p a litre on 24 February to 155.35p a litre a week or so ago following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. An increase of 126 per cent.
Environmentalists might again chorus ‘and a good thing too’. We HAVE to wean ourselves off burning fossil fuels in order to address – if not arrest – climate change. And it’s government policy. Meeting our net zero targets would potentially require a 65% reduction in use of gas by 2035 – nudging 100% by 2050. What’s not to like? Well, put simply, it’s the scary alternatives.
Toxic Chemicals
Suddenly fracking is back on the agenda. Local campaigners in Kent and Sussex – and indeed nationally – believed they had seen off the threat of this environmentally destructive process and packed up their
web pages. The likelihood of earthquakes was worrying enough even before anyone looked at the danger to underground aquifers as toxic chemicals, sand and water are pumped at high pressure into the well to create ‘fissures’ in the shale rock and release the ‘trapped’ natural gas or oil. Trouble is, it’s extremely lucrative for those that carry it out, so it’s little surprise that a whole bunch of right-wing Tory MPs, preferring profit to prudence, are actively backing it again. And burning shale gas will do absolutely nothing for net zero aspirations.
Autocratic Eastern Potentates
Whether or not fracking finds favour with Boris – and his environmentally aware wife Carrie – remains to be seen. By the time you read this he may already have unveiled what Downing Street were, in advance, terming a ‘radical new energy strategy’. But this seems to have less to do with either fundamental fuel poverty, or COP26 commitments. Instead it’s more the realisation that our energy supplies are mainly controlled by autocratic Eastern potentates with no regard for human rights – viz Ukraine, or autocratic Middle Eastern potentates with no regard for human rights – viz Saudi’s mass executions. So the UK’s
new strategy will be based on ‘national security’ considerations. Something that successive governments might possibly have been considering since OPEC turned off the taps in 1973 leading to a quadrupling of oil prices and petrol rationing in the UK.
But let’s not look back in anger. Let’s look forward with perhaps a tad of scepticism. Yes, energy security will be a ‘good thing’ (just as food security might), and the likely concentration on wind power would seem a clean and virtuous alternative. Just one that will take a long time to achieve. And one that does need a back-up for those cold, still, winter days with no wind to turn the
turbines.
Nuclear Back-up Plan
So we can expect nuclear power as the likely back-up plan. And while the mega-wattage (and multi-megabucks) Hinkley C-style stations take their time – the pocket-sized Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) are relatively quick and cheap to install (relative here being around £1.8 billion
over a 4 or 5-year timescale). The slight advantage they have over Hinkley C is that they do not rely on Chinese components! The slight disadvantage is that – watt for watt – they produce more nuclear waste. For which we still have no safe storage or disposal facilities. Oh, and there is one other disadvantage to any nuclear plant, big or small. The core material, uranium, comes mainly (85%) from six countries: Kazakhstan, Canada, Australia, Namibia, Niger and – wait for it – Russia. So if you are talking about energy security you’ve got a problem. Kazakhstan borders Russia and China. Namibia and Niger might be relatively stable at the moment but are part of a continent that is witnessing massive Chinese influence and investment.
Rip Out Your Radiators
Even if you can generate clean and secure electricity, what are you going to do with it? The government’s answer seems to be to use it to run heat pumps which will take over from gas and oil boilers. Except that they won’t. A recent ‘built environment’ think-tank, the BRE, reported: “The UK has the oldest housing stock in Europe, and most likely in the world… as such, it presents unique challenges in making it fit for the future.” And heat pumps are simply not suitable for older, draughtier buildings. Ask any heating engineer about retro-fitting one in an old building and they just laugh. “You’d have to rip out every radiator and replace them with ones double the size,” one told me, “and even then you’d struggle to get the place up to a semi-comfortable 20 degrees.” Plus the technology requires loads of electricity. Given the cost of SMRs or forests of new wind turbines, that power will not come cheap.
It’s a rather depressing picture. We need to stop importing oil and gas for energy security reasons. But in the short-term we are reliant on those fuels. We could increase the output of our own North Sea oil facilities… except we can’t if we are to meet our COP26 commitments. We can expand our wind power programmes… except that they need a nuclear back-up. We could build more small nuclear reactors… except that the uranium to power them comes from
often insecure and dirty mines AND we have no way of dealing with the waste. And, anyway, just producing copious quantities of electricity won’t mean heat pumps become a viable alternative to fossil fuel boilers.
Oven-Ready Lagoon project
One letter to The Guardian recently recommended revisiting the decision to abandon the Cardiff Bay tidal barrage: “There is already an ‘oven-ready’ Swansea tidal lagoon project, fully costed, and with planning approval. The government failed to back it in 2018.” said Roger Critchley. Another writer stressed the importance of decoupling energy production from ‘the market’. A pound to a penny neither will find favour in Boris’ ‘radical new energy strategy’.
We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.


Leave a Reply