Post Office Ltd – How Not to Run a Business
ROD WEBB
The Great Post Office Scandal is responsible for ruining the lives of more than 700 sub-postmasters. Find how this happened when Nick Wallis comes to Hastings to talk about his book of the same name.

During the campaign against the downgrading of the St Leonards Crown Post Office in 2017 (See Issue 117, St Leonards Post Office, Smiling Bravely), those involved became aware of various tactics being used by Post Office Ltd to make it difficult – or almost impossible – to deal with them. One of those tactics was to give the impression that ours was an isolated campaign; this helped prevent the story getting any traction in the wider media. It was a tactic of ‘isolate and control’.
Once this had become clear, we began searching for other communities in a similar position. But this was also difficult because none of the stories had got any traction. The same tactic was used in what is now known as ‘the Great Post Office Scandal’ through the book of the same name by Nick Wallis. Nick will be giving a talk in Hastings on 10 May at the Pig in Hastings. In the meantime, here is some of what happened.
24 YEARS AND COUNTING
The scandal can be traced back to 1999 with the introduction of a computer accounting system called Horizon, which wrongly detected the existence of financial discrepancies at multiple post office branches. This led to the unjust prosecution of hundreds of sub-postmasters who were blamed for these discrepancies and accused of theft and false accounting. The scandal still remains unresolved 24 years after it began, almost a quarter of a century ago – back when the Millennium Dome was still being built.
In 2019, Lord Arbuthnot said in a debate in the House of Commons: “My own suggestion is that the government should clear out the entirety of the board and senior management of the Post Office and start again…” And yet four years from then, with many already dead, those affected have still not received proper redress.
I thought I understood much of what had happened during those 24 years; I had followed the case on the news and listened to some of Nick Wallis’s blog on the BBC. But I still wasn’t prepared for the shocking revelations in his book. It’s 508 pages long and I felt somewhat daunted as I recently carried my copy home from Bookbusters. But it’s a gripping, if harrowing, read and as they say ‘unputdownable’. Dame Joan Bakewell, quoted on the back cover, concurs: “Nick’s narrative has the power of a great thriller as he lays bare the lies and deceit that has ruined many lives.”
Reading about those ruined lives and the relentless pursuit of innocent people provides an uncomfortable insight into aspects of government and business practices that have been allowed to flourish and which have been highlighted by the recent pandemic. What is so shocking is how the callous disregard shown towards sub-postmaters by Post Office Ltd has continued right up until today.
Recent appalling behaviour relates to the way the few compensation payments – which took many years to be made – were swiftly swallowed up: loss of earnings over many years were paid as if earned in one year, pushing tax into a higher earning bracket. One victim, who lost his home as well as his wife over the scandal, eventually received £330,000 in compensation, only to have most of it snatched back in bankruptcy and tax payments, leaving him with £8,000. A tax lawyer, Dan Neidle, has described the government handling of compensation as scandalous.
THE ROOT OF ALL EVIL
At this point you might be wondering why Post Office Ltd went to such lengths to blame sub-postmasters for losses that they had no control over. The answer, as usual, is money. The Horizon system had to be seen to be working or it could not meet government objectives, and Post Office Ltd wanted to meet those objectives (which changed during the period of the scandal). Post Office Ltd, which receives income from the Post Office network, had been making a loss; when the Royal Mail was sold off in 2012, the subsidy it had been obtaining had to be paid by the government. This led to a culture of making a profit at all costs.
These changes intensified the need to hold sub-postmasters accountable for losses rather than the Horizon IT system they were using. As Private Eye wrote in a special report:
“Misleading parliamentarians was a measure of the arrogance in the Post Office boardroom… One Post Office insider told the Eye that meeting the 2020 objective became the relentless focus… Anything that could get in the way of ‘2020’ as it became known, was logged as a risk to be managed and minimised carefully.”
And the tactic used throughout was one of ‘isolate and control’ reminiscent of the behaviour often found in domestic abuse cases, coercive control, now illegal in the UK.
LOCAL VICTIMS
This was the case with East Sussex victims Bob and Kathy Crane. “You are the only ones having problems with Horizon,” was the phrase used by Post Office investigators in 2008, when, in front of their young children, the investigators turned out the drawers in the family home near Ocklynge Road Post Office, Eastbourne, looking for evidence of theft.
Katy Crane, the daughter of the late Bob Crane, trained as a children’s nurse at the Conquest and went to school at St Richards, Bexhill. She will be interviewed by Nick Wallis at the event on May 10.
To obtain tickets go to bathpublishing.com.
We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.


Leave a Reply