Cunning Men, Witches & Devils
DAVID EP DENNIS
It’s 1593. What is a mother to do when her precious child is sick? There is no NHS, no internet or mobile phones. The vicar’s prayers are no use and the town of Rye, where the poor widow Elizabeth (Lizzie) Drynkwater is living, is in serious trouble for hiding its fish catches and not offering them to the monarch for first pick. Powerful men: Rye’s MP Robert Bett, the Lord Warden of the Cinque Ports Sir William Brooke, 10th Baron Cobham – one of the Queen’s spies – and Sir Francis Knollys, Queen Elizabeth I’s courtier, are all hovering over everything that happens in Rye.

Yet there is no doubt that Mrs Drynkwater’s child is sick, so off to Hastings she must go, where, it is said, there lives a cunning man called Zacharius. Upon arrival, Lizzie finds out that the cunning man lodges in the High Street with a fellow called Goodman Combes. When Lizzie arrives at Zachary’s lodgings, there are two large women blocking the doorway. “I’ve come from Rye on the back of my good friend’s horse,” says Lizzie. “My child is sick, let me in.”
Sly and crafty, Zachary listens and smiles. He informs Lizzie that her child has been bewitched by Mother Rogers and tells her that to make her child well again, she must take a knife and plunge it into Mother Rogers’ buttocks. And so back she goes to Rye, and sure enough, Mother Rogers and her cat are just by Lizzie’s door. Lizzie invites her into the kitchen. However, taking the knife, Lizzie loses the courage for a frenzied buttock-stabbing, and instead pricks Mother Rogers in the hand. The witch runs out of the kitchen to salve her wound, and suddenly Lizzie’s child is well again. It is a miracle, thanks to the Cunning Man of Hastings.
A DISCOVERY OF CUNNING
Across the whole of Britain there were people known as ‘cunning folk’. They were not witches in the notorious mediaeval sense, but they did delve into the arcane arts. For example, as late as 1810, in the north of England, there was a cunning man called Wrightson who was the seventh son of a seventh daughter and who could kill a witch’s spell using “pin-sticking, bottery-tree magic and heart frizzling.”
There were, of course, cunning women too. They could diagnose witchcraft and inform the witchfinders, make people love one another using spells and heal sick animals and humans. Eventually, people and the state woke up to realise this was all fakery and mumbo-jumbo, except for the positive use of psychology – that if you do this all will be well – and of course the use of herbal medicines that really worked. However, in the case of Margaret, Lady Sondes, daughter of Sir Francis Knollys, who became insane, Elizabeth I’s astrologer, Dr John Dee, had to be called in to investigate, and thankfully he removed Satan from her: “Dr Dee hath delivered the Lady Sondes of a devil or of some other strange possession.”

In Sussex and in Hastings, there were few witch trials compared to the rest of England and indeed Europe. Sussex authorities prosecuted three men and thirteen women for witchcraft between 1558 and 1736, but only four were hanged. In those days, the pillory was used for all sorts of punishments. An irritating citizen of Rye had his ear nailed to the pillory, while Alice Casselowe who had bewitched a pig and an ox, had died in the pillory.
If you refused to plead guilty or not guilty, you could be pressed to death using huge boulders. This was because under mediaeval common law, a method of torture known as ‘Peine forte et dure’ (Law French for “forceful and hard punishment”) involved placing heavier and heavier stones upon a defendant who refused to plead (“stood mute”), until a plea was entered, or fatal suffocation occurred. The idea was to coerce defendants to submit to the court’s jurisdiction. Sometimes defendants charged with capital offences refused to plead to escape forfeiture of property, allowing their heirs to inherit their estate. ‘Peine forte et dure’ was abolished in Great Britain in 1772.
All sorts of strange practices were undertaken by the vengeful few who really did want to do harm. For example, one so-called witch had kept sides of beef, and as they rotted in the open air of her yard, so too were the people she had cursed expected to rot away. However, the many laws against these cunning and witchlike practices implemented the terrible deaths by burning and hanging of thousands. Two-thousand five hundred ‘witches’ were executed in Scotland alone. Most victims were old and poor. For those of you who would like to read the original Cunning Man record in East Sussex Archives, here it is:
Deposition of Elizabeth Drynkwater – 18 January 1593
“She sayeth that she supposeinge her childe to be bewytched by reason the same was very weake, she went to Hastinge to one Zacharias, who lodgeth within Goodman Combes, whome she had hard to be a connynge man, to know of him what her child lacked, who told to this examynat that one Mother Rogers had bewytched her child and gave her councell to fetch blodd of her in takeinge a knyffe and to thrust it in her buttocke, but she tooke another corse for she prycked her in the hande and thereupon presently her child tooke rest and 2 great gerles dyd heare when the said Zachary gave her that councell.”
Apparently, Zachary had all his arcane books taken from him and given to a Hastings vicar for safekeeping.
Further Reading:
The History of Magic – From Alchemy to Witchcraft, from the Ice Age to the Present (Gooden, C. 2021)
Magisteria – The Entangled Histories if Science and Religion (Spencer, N. 2023)
The Arch-Conjuror of England – John Dee (Parry, G. 2013)
We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.


Leave a Reply