ROB BOUCNIK

On the basis of a ‘strong in all areas’ Ofsted report last summer (between Good and Outstanding under the old system) and a massive jump in GCSE pass rates in English and Maths over the last three years, Ark Alexandra Academy has been shortlisted for UK ‘School of the Year’.

The current image has no alternative text. The file name is: NEWS-Ark-1-Large.jpeg

It seems an incredible turnaround from two years ago when University of Brighton Academy Trust lost its contract with our local schools. At a subsequent meeting of parents and stakeholders held by Hastings & Rye MP Helena Dollimore, the consensus was almost universal to reject Ark as a replacement for UBAT.

Ms Dollimore commented at the time: “It will rightly be seen as a victory for our community that Ark has not been handed control over more of our local schools. I have fed your experiences and concerns directly to the Regional Schools Commissioner who will be taking these up with Ark’s leadership. In this process, these experiences have been heard, and Ark must now work with the community, not against it, and be more responsive to the serious concerns raised.”

So what have Ark done to change their fortunes so dramatically? They were not forthcoming when asked, but just issued a self-congratulatory press release:”We’re proud of the significant progress that Ark Alexandra has made in the last few years. GCSE results in English and maths have risen by 22 percentage points since 2023, and Ofsted recently rated the school Strong in all areas, highlighting its rapid improvement, ambitious curriculum, and support for SEND and vulnerable pupils. Our nomination for Secondary School of the Year is testimony to the hard work, dedication and ambition of staff, students, parents and carers … reflecting rising educational achievement across the local area”.

- Advertisement -
St Michaels Hospice Run Advert

Why not share the methods used to make this improvement? Probably because they do not want to publicize some of them.

COMPASS POINT

Ofsted did praise the school’s SEND delivery although certain aspects of their practice could not be described as inclusive. Students with formal needs are sent to a separate part of the campus known as Compass. Originally set up as a behaviour unit, it now acts as a station for the main school where anyone deemed unable to conform or achieve, for any reason, is sent, usually permanently, though they often promise otherwise at the start. Compass pupils are not allowed to take full curriculum options; instead they go through drill and manual work to prepare a return to the mainstream. They are also excluded from mixing with those in the main school.

A former teacher at the school described the insistence on stillness and upright posture in class as an unreasonable demand on neuro-divergent pupils, especially when non-compliance can result in sanctions as severe as detention. Minor infringements of uniform policy may meet with the same punishment. Such strict behaviour management has its upside in minimising disruption, but the downside is a lot of students leaving. According to the DfE, the numbers in the school year groups seven to nine two years ago had shrunk by 16% as of January this year (in the course of becoming years nine to eleven). Ms Dollimore has described the departure of 472 pupils over the last three years as an “exodus”, concluding: “Everybody agrees we need strict discipline in our schools, but the way this is being implemented is causing a lot of issues and ultimately leading to children falling out of the education system.”

Many parents also complain they cannot contact the school to discuss issues, and the silence does leave Ark open to the accusation that they are reducing the cohort to improve percentage pass rates.

REASONS FOR UPTURN

But surely due credit must be awarded for the dramatic upturn in results and the positive report from Ofsted? A genuine positive is that senior staff are now teaching, including the Head Teacher, unlike under UBAT and other trusts where a multitude of principals, deputies and assistant principals escape from the classroom to administer, delegate and monitor. Unlike local authority-controlled schools, academies have complete control of their budgets; Ofsted clearly feels Ark are directing their resources effectively. But their positivity may be partly due to Ark’s unique policy of drilling a script for teachers to recite to both students and inspectors present during inspection.

Is this turnaround too good to be true? The success is undoubted but, as many point out, it may need to be qualified. If Ark wish to contest the views of many staff, parents and senior local figures and explain the positive steps they have taken, their response could benefit other educators.

In short, what advice did the Regional Commissioner give them two years ago, and how were these recommendations implemented? With a plain answer, the bid for School of the Year would see fewer raised eyebrows among the raised glasses.


We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. You can also support local journalism by becoming a friend of HIP. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.

https://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/NEWS-Ark-1-Large-1024x768.jpeghttps://www.hastingsindependentpress.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/NEWS-Ark-1-Large-150x150.jpegHIPNewsArk Alexandra Academy,Helena Dollimore,ROB BOUCNIK,University of Brighton Academy TrustROB BOUCNIK On the basis of a ‘strong in all areas’ Ofsted report last summer (between Good and Outstanding under the old system) and a massive jump in GCSE pass rates in English and Maths over the last three years, Ark Alexandra Academy has been shortlisted for UK ‘School of...The Hastings & St Leonards non-profit community newspaper