Bailiffs are not being held to account when they break the rules because the complaints system is complicated and intimidating, according to new research from Citizens Advice. Figures obtained by Citizens Advice from the Ministry of Justice show just 56 complaints were made through a court-based process introduced as part of the bailiff reforms in 2014.

In their report, Citizens Advice also revealed that 72% of people who experience a bailiff breaking the rules do not complain at all.

Interviews with advisers and people who have sought help from Citizens Advice shows people do not complain because:
• It is unclear how to make a complaint
• The pressure of bailiff enforcement action puts people off complaining
• There is a lack of faith in the process

Previous research from the national charity revealed that bailiffs broke the rules 850,000 times in the past two years. The lack of an effective complaints system means bailiffs are not held to account.

The report was released on the same day that MPs were set to debate bailiff regulation and receive a response from a justice minister. As part of the “Taking Control” group on bailiff reform, Citizens Advice is calling on the government to introduce a bailiff regulator and establish an independent complaints process.

Government reforms introduced in 2014, which included rules for bailiffs to obey, have not worked because they have not been properly enforced, the charity says. There has been a 24% rise in people coming to Citizens Advice with bailiff problems since 2014. The charity helped one person make a complaint after a bailiff aggressively pursued a parking fine that actually related to their son, who lived elsewhere. The money was eventually refunded, but only after 18 months work with the enforcement agency’s independent adjudicator. In comparison, the Financial Conduct Authority  requires firms to resolve all claims within 8 weeks.

Gillian Guy, Chief Executive of Citizens Advice, said “Bailiffs are getting away with breaking rules designed to protect those who are struggling. The complaints process is complicated and frustrating. People lack faith in a system where you’re required to complain to the bailiff’s firm in the first instance. Bad practice by bailiffs is widespread and causes stress, anxiety and further financial harm. The government has said it wants to end this for good, and to do so, it must bring rule-breaking bailiffs into line by establishing an independent regulator. Alongside this, the Ministry of Justice should introduce an independent complaints process. It’s important complaints are reviewed independently of the bailiff industry and outside the court system.”

The full report can be downloaded from the Citizens Advice website here (tinyurl.com/ycxmhnqt)


We hope you have enjoyed reading this article. The future of our volunteer led, non-profit publication would be far more secure with the aid of a small donation. It only takes a minute and we would be very grateful.